Smartest breeds aren't always the easiest — let's talk about that
I want to push back gently on something I see constantly: people choosing a breed because it's ranked "most intelligent," assuming that means it'll be easy to live with. Nova is a Border Collie — consistently ranked at or near the top of canine intelligence — and I can tell you intelligence is a double-edged sword. A smart dog learns your bad habits as fast as your good ones. A smart dog gets bored, and a bored intelligent dog invents problems you didn't know were possible. Intelligence means higher needs, not lower. The "easiest" dogs to own are often the moderately intelligent, eager-to-please breeds, not the geniuses. Curious whether others have found the same with their high-IQ breeds.
43
This is such an important point, Jasmine! I think people see those "top 10 smartest dogs" lists and imagine a dog that basically trains itself, when really it's the opposite. Honey's a Golden and she's plenty smart but mostly she's just devoted, which honestly makes daily life so much easier than what my Border Collie friends deal with. Different kind of dog entirely.
True. Ranger's a Lab — not winning any genius awards — but he's easy because he just wants to please. My brother's Border Collie runs circles around him intellectually and is ten times the work. Smart isn't simple.
This aligns with how intelligence is actually categorized in the research — Stanley Coren's framework separates instinctive, adaptive, and working/obedience intelligence, and they're not the same thing. A dog can rank high on problem-solving and low on biddability, which is precisely the combination that frustrates owners. "Smartest" rankings usually measure obedience-trainability, which people then misread as "easy." The distinction matters a lot at purchase time.
100% correct. Blitz is scary smart and that's exactly the problem for most owners. Intelligence + drive with no outlet = destruction. People want the smart dog for the bragging rights and then can't handle what comes with it. The eager-to-please mid-tier breeds are far more forgiving of owner mistakes.